In a perfect world, Grammy Award-winning Hockaday alumna Lisa Loeb would be working on a new album of GEICO-inspired hits like You Just Filed a Claim to My Heart.
The singer-songwriter performed a heart-wrenching reprise of her ’90s hit Stay in the latest spot for the insurance company. Although Cracked Windshield brought the cameraman to tears, the casting directors decided to move in a different direction.
Loeb joins sports announcer Dick Vitale and workout instructor Billy Blanks as the latest celebrities to fail their GEICO claims auditions.
Watch the audition and see for yourself. Her angelic voice might just make you consider switching.